Arguments for:
-How has he never been the Sexiest Man Alive? He’s the biggest movie star in the world right now.
-The Avengers comes out in a few months. It’ll be MASSIVE.
-Everyone loves him, loves him, loves him and they love his comeback story
-Stable family life, just had a baby, babies are irresistible – especially with an exclusive on the cover of PEOPLE magazine?
-Nerd vote
-Dude vote

Arguments against:
-The Judge
-He doesn’t need it. He doesn’t need it at all.

Odds: 10 to 1

CLICK HERE to read the Sexiest Man Alive introduction and criteria post.