Everyone on our liveblog loved the print on this dress. I just think sometimes the right dress gets the wrong wearer. Or the right wearer picks the wrong dress. You can decide which sentence works for you in this particular instance but whatever you choose, the point is, Sarah Michelle Gellar and the dress did not make a good match.

Maggie Gyllenhaal? Yes. SJP? Yes too. Christina Ricci? Totally.

On this, I just don’t think Gellar has it what it takes.