❗
Disclaimer: This article was posted during an early period of the site when some of the writing was extremely offensive. Since then our site has grown and evolved. We have apologised, continue to take accountability, and documented our changes. Please see our FAQ on our About page for our formal statement.

Arguments for:

  • He’s Brad Pitt. He’s always in contention
  • He is a two time holder of the SMA title. No man has ever been awarded 3 times. If there’s to be a first, he would be it
  • The year of the Holy Twins and People scored the official photos. There could also be a deal in the works, especially since Team Pitt will be pushing for an Oscar run
  • Benjamin Button has the early Oscar lead
  • Has been active socially with Make It Right and his stance against Prop 8
  • The intoxicating appeal of the current iteration of Brad Pitt as a doting father and family man
  • Oprah asked him back


Arguments against:

  • Has enough time passed? Angelina Jolie is a polarising figure. And curiously enough, he and Jennifer Aniston go head to head on Christmas day as Marley & Me will be released along with Benjamin Button
  • 3 times is overkill, non?
  • He looks tired
  • Brange fatigue


ODDS: 5 to 1

Share this post