Disclaimer: This article was posted during an early period of the site when some of the writing was extremely offensive. Since then our site has grown and evolved. We have apologised, continue to take accountability, and documented our changes. Please see our FAQ on our About page for our formal statement.

Arguments for:

  • I don’t know… supposedly he’s a ladies’ man and horny women want him and they would cut each other for the right to stuff money in his 300 diaper
  • He sings. So this must mean he’s the true Phantom of the Opera.
  • Fake romance with Jennifer Aniston = MiniVan approval because she is THEM.
  • Ten thousand movies released within the last 5 months including a romantic comedy with Katherine Heigl that performed reasonably well at the box office
  • Good job on Saturday Night Live
  • He loves himself. He thinks he deserves it


Arguments against

  • Ew
  • Ew
  • Gross
  • Gross
  • Spittle
  • Nasty mouth
  • Lindsay Lohan…although this must be why he’s been so desperate to refute those rumours
  • Too much of a player
  • Not American. And again, if a non-American is going to take this, a young Brit stands a better chance over a bloaty Scot


Odds: 7 to 1

Share this post