Practically the only category at the Oscars this year which is even close to decided is Best Actress. Julianne Moore pretty well has it on lock for her performance in The Debut, which is genuinely incredible and one of the best of her career. Which is really saying something given her career!

If she does win, it will be her second Oscar, following 2015’s Still Alice. But just because she’s the frontrunner—basically the only uncontested of this Oscar cycle so far—doesn’t mean Julianne Moore is phoning it in. She is NOT. She showed up to the Governors Awards in a great animal print Bottega Veneta gown:

While Julianne is coming for that second trophy, the rest of the Best Actress category is a toss-up. Even though there is a clear frontrunner in the category, no one is throwing in the towel, EVERYONE is gunning for one of the four remaining nominations. And they were all at the Governors Awards.

Inde Navarrette is everywhere right now, along with director Curry Barker, keeping Obsession front and center in awards season. The genre bias is real, and Obsession has to clear that hurdle, but it is easier in a wide-open year, and Obsession is helped by being one of the box office success stories this year for original films.

Curry Barker and Inde Navarrette doing whatever this is at the Governors Awards

Olivia Wilde is campaigning not only as an actress but also as a director, and she could well land that double nomination. Industry people f-cking LOVED The Invite, and right now, I have Olivia penciled in for both categories, with the caveat that I will be revisiting her Best Director odds after Dune: Part Three hits and Denis Villeneuve enters the lists for real.

And don’t forget Sandra Hüller, who could also be a double nominee for her supporting performances in either Project Hail Mary or Digger, though she is notably throwing her effort behind her German-language film Rose, though there is also some heat on her performance in Pawel Pawlikowski’s Fatherland. Truly a huge year for Hüllerheads, I think she is a virtual lock for a nomination, it’s just a question of which film gets her the nod.

Then there are the bubble actresses, scrambling for the fifth nomination. Ruth Madeley from Being Heumann turned up, as did Sophie Okonedo (Mouse), Lea Seydoux (Gentle Monster), Virginie Efira (All of a Sudden), Jeon Do-yeon (Possible Love), and Carrie Coon (The Liberation). Gentle Monster is weird, so Lea Seydoux probably has the longest odds in this group, but Jeon Do-yeon is getting a huge push for Lee Chang-dong’s first feature film since 2018’s Burning, while Sophie Okonedo and Carrie Coon can both play the “everyone knows and likes me” prom queen card.

There is also, of course, Zendaya, who is campaigning for Best Actress for Dune: Part Three. She showed up in archival Gilles Deacon, a Dune-ish dress that isn’t costumey or too theme-y for the night. This strategy matters as she pushes for the same kind of validation from her film peers that she has already gotten by way of her television peers with the Emmys.

Honestly, I think Z is a longshot, even if Dune hits big. Neither Dune movie to date has garnered any acting nominations, which is not reflective of the quality of those performances, but more reflective of how people THINK about those movies. They’re craft movies, first and foremost, not unlike Lord of the Rings, which only ever banked one acting nod (for Ian McKellan in Fellowship of the Ring). I won’t be surprised if Dune ends up with similar numbers.

But with the Oscars so wide open, and with the pool of films genuinely strong this year, it really is down to the popularity contest of it all. When the films and performances are this strong, the Oscars are not really about merit, because at a certain level, they’re all deserving of recognition, and judging art like sports is dumb and bad, and yes, people actually DO know this.

I’ve seen people push back against the “prom court” nature of the Oscars, like it SHOULDN’T be a popularity contest, but when the Oscars leans on likeability, it just means everyone is agreeing that wow, there were so many good films and performances and excellent work this year, so yeah, I AM going to vote for my friend, or that one actor I’ve always admired who’s never won an Oscar before (paging John Malkovich). People start considering other factors because we’re working from a baseline of “this was a very good year” and the judgment comes not necessarily from a strict assessment of work but from considering other factors like who is popular, likeable, and “deserving” based on “it’s their time”.

An Academy voter once explained to me that he doesn’t think of “Best” as in “best, better than all the rest”, but “best all around”. Best Picture is the film that feels the most complete top to bottom; and that when selecting Best Actress, or any other acting category, he is thinking about the performance that is the most memorable, the most emotionally effective, and the one that makes him forget about the actor for a couple of hours. I always liked that explanation, and I use it as a guide when doing my own awards voting.

I think about the performances I never forgot, the moments that keep popping back into my mind. A vote for “best” isn’t a statement that I think Julianne Moore is actually a better actor than Sandra Hüller, they’re both phenomenal, but maybe I thought about one performance a little more than another throughout the year. Just something to keep in mind when doing your Oscar pools this year. Popularity is going to matter this year. Likeability is going to matter. You’re not handicapping the best actress of 2026, you’re handicapping the 2026 Hollywood Prom Queen.

Photo credits: Matt Baron/BEI/Chelsea Lauren/Shutterstock

Share this post