Well this was predictable.

At the end of the last award season – which was only earlier this year – Timothée Chalamet completed the process of what we call a “heel turn” in storytelling, transitioning from being a cultural favourite to the culture’s favourite villain. The backlash had been bubbling for months, with some calling him arrogant for his SAG Award speech in 2025, during which he said he was aspiring to greatness, which led into the Marty Supreme press tour and the various displays of obnoxious in service of his character, a thoroughly unlikeable narcissist that became a blurring of fact and fiction between the role and the person.

Now it’s time for Dune: Part 3 and the timing couldn’t be better… or worse. Because in the third and final installment of Denis Villeneuve’s cinematic franchise, Paul Atreides is the ultimate villain, a megalomaniac mass murderer played by Timmy who is now on promotion. He covers the new issue of Vanity Fair.

To go back to what was predictable, as noted at the beginning of this post, what’s predictable is that this is the most reticent Timothée Chalamet has ever been in a magazine profile. This interview is a nothingburger – he says nothing and he admits to wanting or needing to say nothing or, rather, the other side of that coin, which is that he is afraid to say anything.

The piece is reported by Vanity Fair editor Mark Guiducci who writes that:

In our 90 minutes together, Chalamet is both earnest and also reluctant to be profiled. He is by turns generous and guarded, confident and careful. He prefaces answers to no fewer than seven different questions by saying that he doesn’t want to sound “pretentious.” Truthfully, he never does. He’s protective of his personal life and will not discuss his girlfriend, nor much outside of filmmaking. “I wish I didn’t have to talk too much,” Chalamet says. 

It’s a textbook celebrity response to a period of backlash. This is what most of them do after criticism – they retreat, and while retreating they talk about why they are retreating, and the reason is never… well… I chose my words poorly, it’s almost always because their words were misinterpreted, used against them, unfairly taken out of context.

So many of Timmy’s predecessors have done the same, from Tom Cruise to Bradley Cooper to Leonardo DiCaprio, so he’s following in the footsteps of, I suppose, a certain kind of greatness – by the definition of those insulated by their celebrity. Which is ironic, at least to me, because for someone who wants to be such an original, this is a basic bitch response.

And his response to that would probably be, yeah, but that’s not my work. My work should speak for itself. Unsurprisingly he said that too:

“My work is my bones and muscles. I have little interest in putting more of myself out there.”

Girl, this is the job description when you want to make things that people see; when you want to work in film; when you’re starring in one of the biggest blockbusters of the year; and not, um, ballet and opera where, by the way, the artists do actually want to put more of themselves out there and have as many microphones in their faces as possible to generate more interest.

It actually would have been more punk of him to keep talking, to continually revise, because Timothée Chalamet, like it or not, is a Movie Star, one of the biggest of his generation. As we just saw with the James Bond casting, Movie Stars were prematurely declared dead – it turns out Movie Stars might be not be inferior to IP after all. He won’t get any less famous, there won’t be fewer opportunities to talk, only more, since he’s now 30 and entering what might be a peak phase of his career with more roles opening up to him… if you can believe it, considering his already impressive resumé. Not talking isn’t an option.

And, sorry, but these photos in Iceland, don’t sustain as much interest as they think it will.

 

Photo credits: Matt Baron/BEI/Shutterstock

Share this post