Intro for September 15, 2026

Dear Gossips,

The 78th Emmys were tight, if not sharp, with an overwhelming story of triumph for freshman comedy-thriller Widow’s Bay.  Star Matthew Rhys had  a historic double win for acting in two categories, a surprise that made the Widow’s Bay sweep all the sweeter.

…or did it?

Did we really see what we think we saw, or are we just kidding ourselves? Letting ourselves be spooked by a story, even though we know better, or we should, anyway? Is the influence of Widow’s Bay a little too effective? If you’re reading this, I know you know what, and specifically who, we’re talking about – but, like any good creepy story that may or may not be real, the whole point is in the telling of it. So let’s start at the beginning…

Everyone knew, early on, that Widow’s Bay was dramatic and different and was making a big impact. Voter polls were definitely leaning towards at least substantial representation. So when Kate O’Flynn won off the top of the show, the zeitgeist was welcomed into the room and everyone was celebratory, including and especially O’Flynn’s castmate and fellow nominee, Dale Dickey. “This is for all the Patricias out there!”  she crows, definitely a first for women named Patricia (and Trish, and Patsy) and everyone who ever felt like a Patricia in Widow’s Bay, misunderstood and not entirely innocent, but trying, you know?

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by The Ankler (@theankler)

Then, just two awards later, Matthew Rhys wins for The Beast In Me. Very unexpected, absolutely an award that was earmarked for Oscar Isaacs. Everyone was shocked, including Rhys, so of course, all his expected remarks he expected to say about all the people who made Widows fly out of his mind, and he’s dealing with a whole new situation.

You might even call it a twist, or a fakeout…

Because sure, he didn’t say thank you to his wife, but again, he was startled, and we know they’re not schmoopy like that – especially now that everyone’s getting so thirstily parasocial about them all the time, they probably have dialed down any PDA even further. She’s supportive because she’s there, she’s a nominee herself so it’s not like his shout out from the stage is going to be the highlight of her night, and come on – it’s these two, they’re wrapped up in each other all the time, like I posted only yesterday.

There’s no monster in the corner! It was only a shadow!

The night continues, and Widow’s Bay continues to clean the hell up. Matthew Rhys wins again.  Katie Dippold, who really did write a (much more traditional-comedy) version of the script 18 years ago, (that got her a job on Parks & Recreation and impressed showrunner Mike Schur so much he not only wrote “Hire Her” on the front, he pitched it with her for years before she decided something about it wasn’t right and paused to rewrite it) gives the funniest and probably most honest acceptance speech of the night, and we are back in good warm feelings!

Then director Hiro Murai collects a statue! Things are wonderful!

…but online, a certain fog is beginning to roll in…

Jaime Primak Sullivan (@jaimepsullivan) on Threads

Why am i so bothered that Mathew Rhys didn’t thank Keri Russel during Either Emmy win? she probably doesn’t care maybe they have their own thing going, but I really hope that he would.

Threads

Sylvie Jones (@sylvie.j66) on Threads

Am I dreaming? Did Matthew Rhys just win 2 Emmys and didn’t thank his partner Keri Russell once? Or did I sleep through it?

Threads

What’s that? A little chill rolling up your spine? A little doubt creeping in? All of a sudden, all your years of Hollywood conditioning come into play all at once?  “Here we go, he wins two awards and suddenly she doesn’t matter?” “He didn’t even look in her direction.” “Were they weird on the carpet, though? I thought they were fine…”

Because once you allow the idea of something scary as an actual possibility in your mind, it’s never really not there, is it? Never mind that the wins keep on coming for Widow’s Bay – Best Comedy Series! – and nobody who loves their spouse could possibly stay mad after a night like that. Doesn’t matter that they’ve pointed out they don’t thank each other at these things on purpose – that the jokes they do have make it so clear none of this matters, (as Matthew explained ‘She said “If you win both, I’m not coming home with you.” That’s not a joke you make if it’s a real possibility!) you’re still scared, aren’t you?

When you’re really afraid, though, what you need is someone who’s not afraid to turn the lights on and look, unflinchingly, at what’s really there. To be the hero that Rhys’s Mayor Loftis wants to be for the citizens of Widow’s Bay! 

For us? That hero is one of our very own, who asks the real questions:

…and there you have it! Did you hear that? Play it back again. There’s no doubting the joking and affection in his voice. Now, will they pointedly kiss later? Will one of them remind the other that having eaten the onion dip canape or whatever the anti-kiss device was before the show isn’t worth the drama that’s going to ensue?

Maybe. But either way, it’s a happy ending. Breathe a sigh of relief. The lights are on, Widow’s Bay wins a total of 14 Emmys, (including all the major comedy categories except Lead Actress, in which they didn’t have a nominee) and Matthew Rhys, overwhelmed though he may be, is going home quite secure and happy, with the knowledge not only that he’s a multiple winner (he’s also a Widow’s Bay Executive Producer) but that the show’s future, and his, are ironically very bright.

Of course, there’s always next season…

Attached – The cast and crew of Widow’s Bay cleans up.