Shoes Sarah Pidgeon’s shoe surprise After stressing and judging all last year during production, can we now acknowledge that Sarah Pidgeon and Paul Anthony Kelly are doing great jobs on Love Story as Carolyn Bessette Kennedy and John F. Kennedy, Jr.? Because they are. Do they always look 100% like the people they are playing? By Sarah • Mar 03, 2026 11:01 am
TV Updates Love Story on the red carpet Sarah posted yesterday about the trailer for Love Story that dropped earlier this week and her main point was that she didn’t hate it. Neither did I. In fact I was very encouraged by it. There’s a shot of Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette where she’s drinking By Lainey • Feb 04, 2026 01:19 pm
TV Updates JFK Jr and Carolyn’s Love Story We watched on tenterhooks as the latest installment in Ryan Murphy’s “American Story” franchise was filmed in New York last year, and now we have an official trailer by which to judge the renamed Love Story, centered on the ill-fated romance and marriage of John F. Kennedy, Jr. and By Sarah • Feb 03, 2026 11:22 am
TV Updates American Love Story: The Fight Paul Kelly and Sarah Pidgeon were photographed today on the New York set of Ryan Murphy’s American Love Story in their respective roles as John F Kennedy Jr and Carolyn Bessette. The scene they were filming is infamous. Those of us who were/are still obsessed with John and By Lainey • Sep 02, 2025 01:30 pm
Movie Reviews and Previews Carolyn’s Carpenter Jeans Sarah Pidgeon was photographed in New York yesterday as production continues on Ryan Murphy’s American Love Story. Sarah looks so pretty with her hair pulled back like this and her face made up to look like she’s barely wearing any. Though her hair is more honey blonde than By Lainey • Aug 14, 2025 03:02 pm
TV Updates Carolyn Bessette: Kinky hair and the 90s cigarette pant Sarah Pidgeon was photographed in New York in costume as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy yesterday. The hair, as we know, has been a consistent conversation the last few weeks with screen test footage and pap shots that have been released during production. The hair, I think, in these pictures is better than By Lainey • Jul 23, 2025 01:44 pm
Movie Reviews and Previews I Know What You Did Last Summer… and Carolyn Bessette I Know What You Did Last Summer came out in 1997, starring Jennifer Love Hewitt, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Freddie Prinze Jr, and Ryan Phillippe, four major names in pop culture for Gen X and early Millennials. And it was a hit. So now there’s a 2025 version which brings By Lainey • Jul 15, 2025 11:31 am
TV Updates More John and Carolyn Love Story, the John F Kennedy Jr and Carolyn Bessette series that Ryan Murphy has been working on, is a main character this week after he released screen test photos of Paul Kelly and Sarah Pidgeon, the actors playing the iconic couple, and with the paparazzi shooting them filming in By Lainey • Jun 19, 2025 02:18 pm
